Back to Essay Assessing Software Homepage Intelligent Essay Assessor Automated Essay Grading Op Ed Article List of Related Articles

Pros and Cons of Essay Assessing Software
Pros
Cons
Cuts costs of assessing a large volume of essays written for placement tests
Software can assess as many as six documents a second, saving time and providing results more quickly
According to some studies, can be as good as, even better than, human raters in assessing student writing
Can be fed an "ideal" essay and programmed to assess other essays based on this ideal
Not affected by exhaustion or biases, as some human raters may be
Able to flag essays deemed "unusual" in some way, indicating the need for human asssessment

 

Assesses writing based on standards of placement tests; doesn’t distinguish differences in students’ primary discourses
Looks for keywords to interpret meaning and content; unable to assess content holistically
Given to misinterpretation of content, based on keyword searches
More likely to focus on conventions, such as syntactical errors, misspellings, sentence complexity, sentence length and punctuation
Removes consideration of differences of student background, culture, and language from the equation
Does not provide positive feedback; focuses on product, not process

Back to Lori's Homepage