Armitage
Research Group
Eastern
Michigan University
Department
of Chemistry
Analytical Chemistry and Archaeological Science
Our group is involved in several applications of analytical chemistry to archaeological materials, ranging from soils to rock paintings to historic brick. Currently, there are both undergraduates and MS students carrying out research in the group. We use many different analytical techniques, including gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, ATR-FTIR, and x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, to characterize a diverse array of archaeological materials. Our predominant interest is the characterization of the organic matter in rock paintings. This is important to aid in understanding the radiocarbon dates for paintings with no visible organic content.
Some of our projects at EMU
Radiocarbon dating and chemical analysis of organic binders in rock paintings.
Characterization of black coating in Little Lost River Cave: Implications for radiocarbon dating.
“Non-destructive” radiocarbon dating: new pretreatments and surface analyses.
17th Century Brick Composition
Soil Chemistry: Investigating Change During Storage of Excavated Samples
Viability of Using Clinical Test Strips to Indicate Blood in Rock Paintings (long term project)
Other links:
Student research in the lab **New and updated!**
M.S. in Chemistry at EMU
Email Dr. Armitage
Over the past several years, rock paintings from around the world have been radiocarbon dated based on the assumption that they contained some organic material added to the paint as binder or vehicle. The actual material present in the most of these paints remains uncharacterized. To improve the reliability of the radiocarbon results on rock painting samples, we are preparing new paint using some possible binders (blood, bone marrow, egg, plant juices and oils, etc.), applying the paints to limestone and artificially aging them using heat and UV exposure. We are currently using thermally-assisted hydrolysis/methylation-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (THM-GC-MS) to separate and identify components in each binder that will hopefully be useful in then identifying the unknown materials from authentic paintings. Radiocarbon analysis on specific fractions of the organic matter will also be carried out. Infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) has also been used to characterize binders in historic artwork and has so far been used to create a database of spectra for known rock painting binders.
This work has been supported with a Spring-Summer Award for Scholarly Activity from the Office of the Provost, Eastern Michigan University in 2002. University Faculty Research and Creative Activity Fellowships in 2004-2005, Fall 2006, and Winter 2009 have all supported work related to these projects. This is the central project for our group.
These are some of the archaeological projects we have been working on.:
**Featured project**
Cueva La Conga (Nicaragua): This project, in collaboration with Suzanne Baker, from CultureLink in California, seeks to date and chemically characterize the newly-discovered paintings of Cueva La Conga in northern Nicaragua. EMU has made this project possible with an internal grant through the Faculty Research Fellowship program.
Read more about the Cueva La Conga Project:
Casa de Las Golondrinas, (Antigua, Guatemala): Successful radiocarbon dates have been obtained on two samples of rock paintings from this site. This project, done in association with Eugenia Robinson, has resulted in two publications. Link to archaeological paper (from the Guatemalan Archaeology Symposium). Link to chemistry paper (from special issue on Mass Spectrometry in Art).
Hey Shelter, Black Hills National Forest (South Dakota): This project is a collaboration between our lab, Dr. Marvin Rowe, currently of Texas A&M University-Qatar, and Alice Tratebas of the Bureau of Land Management. We have a radiocarbon date for the charcoal image sampled, and plan to publish the results soon.
Pecos River Genre Paintings (Texas): We are using thermally-assisted hydrolysis/methylation-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry to determine if a proteinaceous or carbohydrate-based binder might have been used in these paintings. This is an ongoing project.
Canadian Shield Pictographs (Ontario): This project was initiated by Rex Weeks, an anthropology student at Arizona State University who is studying the pictographs of the Canadian Shield. He currently has funding from NSF for the dating project. Samples from the Royal Ontario Museum will play a major role in this project, as will sampling to take place at Spider Cave in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. The Michigan part of the project is a collaboration with Alex Weeks at Northern Michigan University. We will be working on this project throughout 2009 and into 2010.
Orofino Gulch handprint (Montana): The handprint found at the opening to a historic mine is thought to be an historic fake. In July 2009, we will be sampling the handprint to obtain a date for the paint. This project is a collaboration with Carl Davis of the Forest Service.
Boulder Cave (Montana): Samples of the paintings in Boulder Cave were submitted for analysis and dating. While there may have been an organic binder present in the red paint, it was removed in the process of eliminating contamination from adhering soil. No date could be determined for the paintings of Boulder Cave. This project was a collaboration with Sara Scott, formerly of the Forest Service.
Future projects for which we are currently seeking funding:
Ritter Ranch Pictographs (California): Beth Padon of Discovery Works, a cultural resource management firm in California, has contacted me about dating the pictographs found at Ritter Ranch. This project has already been approved by the local Native groups. Depending on funding, we hope to go to the site, located in the Mojave Desert near Palmdale, sometime to collect samples.
The interior of Little Lost
River Cave (10BT1) in southeastern Idaho is covered with a shiny,
hard, black coating that obscures the rock paintings located
there. Previous studies using stable isotope analysis and
plasma-chemical oxidation/AMS radiocarbon analysis
(Steelman et
al 2002 a&b) revealed
that the black material was likely of an animal origin and of an age
range between 1390 and 1040 cal BC. We have been studying the
coating qualitatively using pyrolysis- and THM-GC-MS and XPS, and
quantitatively using GC-MS of lipids to identify the nature of this
black residue. Several students
have been involved in this work, as has one undergraduate.
Our results indicate that the coating is more consistent with the composition of humic and fulvic acids, which could be deposited by ground water. This project has resulted in two publications and three M.S. theses. A final manuscript, incorporating the most recent lipid quantitative analysis, is currently in preparation. This project is a collaboration with Carolynne Merrell of Archaeographics, Moscow, ID.
The
plasma-chemical oxidation method has been proposed as a
"nondestructive" technique for radiocarbon dating fragile
archaeological artifacts. We are investigating two questions
related to this process: (1) What changes are induced in the surfaces
of materials oxidized using the plasma method, and (2) is there an
appropriate pretreatment method to be used in conjunction with this
nondestructive dating process? Two graduate students have
worked to answer these questions: one developed a THM-GC-MS technique
to evaluate a new chemical pretreatment method, work that has been
carried on by several undergraduates, while the other used FTIR-ATR
to characterize changes in the functionalities at the surface of the
materials after they are exposed to the plasma treatment.
We have now carried out the first independent nondestructive radiocarbon dates on fragile reed and bark artifacts from Little Lost River Cave, Idaho. Publications on this project are in preparation.
17th Century Brick Composition
The fourth English colony in North America, Maryland, had it's first capital at St. Mary's City from 1634-1696. This site, where religious freedom was first set forth as law, is little known compared to Plymouth and Jamestown, though the first Roman Catholic brick building in English America was constructed there around 1667. Though only the foundations of this structure remain, it must have been a massive building, with 25 foot high walls. The bricks used to build the chapel appear different from other bricks used at the site. The chapel bricks contain inclusions ranging in size and color, but are mostly black or purple. We are undertaking an analysis of the bricks using neutron activation analysis to compare the elemental compositions of the bricks and the local St. Mary's County clays and using petrographic analysis of thin sections to identify the mineral inclusions in the bricks. SEM analysis of the nodules is also planned. An undergraduate student presented this work at the ACS National Meeting in New Orleans in 2003. Travel grants from the EMU College of Arts and Sciences, the EMU Chemistry Department, and the Huron Valley ACS local section made her presentation possible. Another undergraduate participated in the final stages of this project and was a co-author on a publication. This work was generously supported by the EMU Department of Chemistry through a small grant for petrographic analysis and release time. This project is now complete.
For more information on the chapel, please see the Historic St. Mary's City research website .
Soil Chemistry: Investigating Change During Storage of Excavated Samples
Soil samples are often retained during an excavation for chemical analysis. Standard soil analyses for agricultural purposes (such as soil phosphate, calcium and pH) can also provide cultural information. Elevated soil phosphate levels indicate human influence, and have been used to survey possible archaeological sites before excavation. Preliminary results of this project were presented at Pittcon 2003 in Orlando, FL. Travel costs were defrayed by grants from the Josephine Nevins Keal Fund and the College of Arts and Sciences. More recently, the work was presented at the Inaugural Symposium for Archaeological Sciences of the Americas in Tucson, AZ. This work was incorporated into a class project for the CSIE Quantitative Analysis laboratory in Winter 2008. Click here for more information about the NSF-funded CSIE@EMU program.
Investigating the Viability of Using Clinical Test Strips to Identify Blood in Rock Paintings
Clinical test strips, developed for urinalysis, have been suggested for rapid analysis of rock paintings as a presumptive test for blood as a binder. This long term study seeks to determine for how long blood can be detected in rock painting samples, and if such tests are appropriate. The preliminary publication for this project is in press in the Proceedings of the International Symposium on Archaeometry from Siena, Italy in 2008. The project is being carried out by Dr. Daniel Fraser of Lourdes College.
Return to top